Blog

World Heritage Sites – Your Questions Answered!

Your Questions Answered

Although most people have heard of the UNESCO World Heritage List, not many people actually know about the process behind it. How are sites selected? How are they maintained? Who pays for it? All of your World Heritage site questions are answered below!

What is a World Heritage Site?

Simply put, a World Heritage Site is a place or landmark that UNESCO (the United Nations Educational Scientific and Cultural Organisation) considers to be of Outstanding Universal Value to humanity. The definition of “Outstanding Universal Value” is intentionally vague, but it basically means the location has value that cuts across political, religious or ethnic lines. World Heritage Sites can be either a single location (eg one building or national park), or it can cover multiple locations (eg a group of similar buildings). Sites are classified as either Cultural heritage, Natural heritage, or Mixed heritage (elements of both Cultural and Natural). Sites can also span countries!

Kakadu National Park

Australia’s Kakadu National Park, a Mixed World Heritage site

How many World Heritage Sites are there?

As of mid-2019, there are 1092 World Heritage Sites. These sites are spread across 167 countries and six continents – there aren’t any in Antarctica (yet!). 845 sites are Cultural, 298 are Natural, and 38 are Mixed.

How are World Heritage Sites judged?

There are ten criteria that UNESCO uses to judge a site. These are:

  1. A masterpiece of human creative genius and cultural significance
  2. An important interchange of human values over a span of time
  3. A unique or exceptional testimony to a cultural tradition or to a civilisation
  4. An outstanding example of a type of building, architectural or technological ensemble which represents a significant stage in history
  5. An outstanding example of a traditional human settlement, land-use or sea-use
  6. Directly associated with events or living traditions, ideas or beliefs
  7. Superlative natural phenomena or areas of exceptional natural beauty
  8. An outstanding example representing major stages of Earth’s history
  9. An outstanding example representing significant on-going ecological and biological processes in evolution
  10. Contains the most important and significant natural habitats for in-situ conservation of biological diversity

Criteria 1-6 apply to Cultural sites, while Criteria 7-10 apply to Natural sites. All 10 Criteria apply to Mixed sites.

How does a site get added to the World Heritage list?

The process is quite long, expensive and time-consuming. It starts with each national government – they put forward places and landmarks they believe are worthy of inclusion on the list. This is accompanied by a large dossier explaining the area covered, why they believe it should be include, and which of the above criteria the potential site meets. It then gets added to the Tentative World Heritage List. As of mid-2019, this has over 1700 entries!

Once on the Tentative list, a site is then Nominated for consideration at the yearly World Heritage Committee meeting (typically held in June). Countries are generally only allowed to nominate one site per year for consideration. Independent assessments of each Nominee site are carried out by the International Council of Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS), and/or the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).

Finally, at the annual Committee meeting, a vote is taken among the 15 members for whether to Inscribe, Defer, or Reject each Nominated site. Members usually vote in line with the recommendations from ICOMOS, though politics sometimes plays a factor! Around 20-25 Nominated sites make it through the process and get added to the official List each year.

Naumburg Cathedral

Naumburg Cathedral in Germany: added in 2018

That sounds like a lot! What’s the benefit?

Being on the World Heritage list brings quite a few benefits! In addition to increased tourism, it also classes the Site as a landmark under the Geneva Convention, (theoretically) preventing it from looting and damage in times of war and civil unrest. It also provides a lot of prestige to a country, announcing its accomplishments to the entire world. But it can also bring drawbacks too, particularly the risks of over-tourism and climate change. Some city-centre sites like Liverpool (UK) and Vienna (Austria) have also found it difficult to strike a balance between new development and heritage requirements.

What were the first World Heritage sites?

In 1978, the first meeting of the World Heritage Committee inscribed twelve sites. These were:

Mesa Verde

Mesa Verde in Colorado, USA. A World Heritage List original from 1978!

So who has the most World Heritage sites?

As of 2019, Italy has the most World Heritage sites with 54. China is right behind with 53 sites, while Spain (47), France (44) and Germany (44) round out the top five. Other heavy hitters include India (37), Mexico (35), the United Kingdom (31) and Russia (28). Around 450 total sites are located in Europe, while about 260 are in Asia and the Pacific. There’s close to 200 in the Americas and Caribbean, 95 in Africa and 84 in the Arab States area.

The Struve Geodetic Arc site is located in 10 different countries, making it the most-widely spread site. The Architectural Work of Le Corbusier is one of the only trans-continental sites, with locations in Switzerland, Belgium, India, Japan, Argentina and others.

For cities, London has the most sites with four (Westminster Abbey & Palace, Tower of London, Maritime Greenwich, and Kew Gardens). Beijing, Berlin, Delhi, Mumbai, Moscow and Mexico City each have three.

Colosseum

The Colosseum, one of Italy’s most famous sites!

What are some record World Heritage sites?

Phoenix Islands Protected Area (Kiribati) is the largest World Heritage site. It covers an ocean territory of over 408,000 square kilometres, to a depth of 6000 metres. Yes, that’s roughly the size of California!

The Holy Trinity Column of Olomouc (Czech) and the Thracian Tomb of Kazanlak (Bulgaria) are tied for the smallest World Heritage site. Both are only a few square metres in area.

Göbekli Tepe (Turkey) is considered the oldest man-made construction on the list, with buildings approximately 10,000-12,000 years old.

The Sydney Opera House (Australia) is the youngest entry. It was only completed in 1973!

It’s hard to determine the most-visited site. However, it’s estimated that several World Heritage sites in China see upwards of 15 million visitors each year. This includes the Great Wall of China, and the Imperial Palace in Beijing. The Taj Mahal (India) and Paris, Banks of the Seine (France) are likely the most visited sites outside of China.

Similarly, it’s hard to know the least-visited site. However, some sites are completely off-limits to visitors! One example is Decorated Cave of Pont d’Arc (France) which doesn’t admit tourists, though an exact replica has been built nearby. There’s also remote, uninhabited islands where tourists are forbidden, such as Gough & Inaccessible Islands (UK), Papahanaumokuakea (USA), and Surtsey (Iceland). And frustratingly, there’s Stoclet Palace (Belgium) located in suburban Brussels. Apparently one of the most beautiful houses of the early 20th century, it’s a private home and has never allowed visitors!

Stoclet Palace

Stoclet Palace, so near and yet so far!

What about World Heritage in Danger?

Our world is constantly changing, and World Heritage sites are no exception. Climate change, natural disasters, human activities and even poor management can have serious consequences for World Heritage sites. As a key part of their mission to preserve the world’s heritage for future generations, UNESCO maintains a separate List of World Heritage in Danger. When a site is placed on the In Danger list, the site’s owners are expected to work closely with UNESCO in managing and solving the problems. Currently there are 54 sites In Danger, including:

  • All six World Heritage sites in Syria, due to the ongoing civil war
  • Everglades National Park (USA), due to damage from Hurricane Andrew
  • Tropical Rainforests of Sumatra (Indonesia), due to illegal poaching and logging
  • Humberstone & Santa Laura Saltpeter Works (Chile), due to poor maintenance and vandalism
  • Mercantile Maritime City of Liverpool (UK), due to overdevelopment

Can a Site Lose World Heritage Status?

Yes! So far, two sites have been removed from the World Heritage list. The Arabian Oryx Sanctuary (Oman) was removed in 2007 at the request of Oman’s ruling sheikh, freeing up space for new oil and gas exploration. More controversially, Dresden Elbe Valley (Germany) was removed in 2009 following construction of a new road bridge. So it’s unlikely to happen, but certainly possible!

Waldschlößchenbrücke - Dresden, Germany

Waldschlößchenbrücke – Dresden, Germany. Image courtesy of user Daderot, Wikimedia Commons

Are there any notable omissions from the World Heritage list?

Certainly. Bagan (Myanmar) is arguably the most significant site missing from the World Heritage list. However, Bagan is nominated for inscription in 2019 and very likely to succeed. Other widely-touted candidates for inscription include Varanasi (India), Santorini (Greece), Mecca (Saudi Arabia), and the Panama Canal (Panama).

Bagan

Bagan, Myanmar. Surprisingly still not a World Heritage site!

Further Reading

Still got questions? Leave us a comment below!

Maybe have a look at some of our other articles!

Or check out our archive of nearly 400 World Heritage site visits on YouTube!

No Comments

    Leave a Reply